Most claims lost in a switch are not lost to bad billing. They fall into the gap between two teams. Here is the cutover, step by step, from reading your contract to the day 90 review, with a planner that turns your notice date into a dated plan.
Last updated November 2026 · Reviewed by the PracticeAlpha billing team
Read your contract first for the notice period, delivery method, data return terms and the business associate agreement. Before giving notice, pull aging by payer, every open claim, unapplied credits, appeals in flight and a list of every login, and check where ERAs go. Then set a cutover date, put in writing which team owns which claims during a short overlap, bill anything near a filing limit, revoke the old team's access on the end date, and review aging weekly for 30 days.
Switching billing companies rarely loses claims because anyone is careless. It loses claims because for a few weeks two teams are touching the same accounts receivable, and each one assumes the other has a particular claim covered. The outgoing team is winding down and not paid to chase things it will never see a fee on. The incoming team is learning your payers and your software. Anything that sits between them can age quietly.
Picture a practice with two dentists and one hygienist schedule. The billing company gets 30 days notice in early March. The old team keeps submitting new claims for a week, then slows down. The new team starts on the 20th and works new claims only. Nobody owns the 40 claims that were submitted in February and are now sitting at 30 to 45 days with no response. By the time someone opens the aging report in May, a handful of them are past the payer's filing or appeal window.
That is the pattern behind almost every messy switch. The fixes are not complicated, but they have to happen in the right order, and most of them have to happen before you give notice.
Every step below exists to close one of those gaps. If you only remember one rule, make it this: every open claim needs one named owner on every day of the transition.
Before you tell your current billing company anything, pull out the signed agreement and every amendment. The contract decides your timeline. It tells you how much notice you owe, how notice has to be delivered, what the company keeps doing while you are leaving, and what you get back at the end.
You are not reading it to pick a fight. You are reading it so your plan fits the terms you already agreed to. Have your attorney review anything unclear; the notes below explain what to look for, not how a court would read your particular contract.
| Clause | What to find | Why it matters in a switch |
|---|---|---|
| Term and renewal | Is it month-to-month, or an annual term that auto-renews? | An auto-renewal date can lock you in for another term if notice arrives a day late. |
| Notice period | How many days, and from when (the date sent, or the date received)? | This sets your end date, which drives every other date in the plan. |
| How notice is given | Email, certified mail, a specific person or address | Notice sent the wrong way may not count. Follow the method exactly. |
| Termination for cause or convenience | Can you leave without a reason? Is there a fee if you do? | Tells you whether you can shorten the notice period and what it costs. |
| Work during notice | Do they keep submitting, following up and posting until the end date? | If the contract says yes, you can hold them to it. If it is silent, you need it in writing. |
| Fees after termination | Do they bill a percentage on collections that arrive after the end date for claims they submitted? | Payments keep arriving for weeks after you switch. Know who gets paid on them. |
| Data ownership and return | Who owns claim notes, appeal letters, reports and work product? In what format and by when do you get them? | Your practice software holds the ledger, but notes and files may live in the vendor's own systems. |
| Business associate agreement | Is there a signed BAA, and what does it say happens to patient data at termination? | This is where return or destruction of protected health information is usually spelled out. |
A billing company that handles your patients' claims is a business associate under HIPAA, and the federal rule lists what that contract has to contain. One required term is that at termination the business associate will, if feasible, return or destroy the protected health information it still holds and keep no copies, or extend the contract's protections if return or destruction is not feasible (45 CFR 164.504(e)(2)(ii)(J)). The same section requires the contract to let you terminate if the business associate violates a material term.
In practice, that means you can ask for written confirmation of what was returned or destroyed once the relationship ends. Put that request in your notice letter so it is not an afterthought. If you cannot find a signed BAA at all, raise it with your attorney now, before you sign the next one.
The day you give notice, the outgoing team's motivation changes, even with good people. So pull everything you need while the relationship is still normal. Most of it comes out of your own practice software, which means you can do it without asking anyone. If you are not sure how to read the aging side of this, our guide to the dental insurance aging report walks through it.
| Report or list | What it should show | Why you need it |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance aging by payer | Open balances in 0 to 30, 31 to 60, 61 to 90 and 90+ day buckets, split by payer | Your baseline. It shows what the old team is leaving behind and where the risk sits. |
| Open claims list | Every submitted, unpaid claim: patient, date of service, payer, amount, date sent, last status | This becomes the handoff list. Every line gets an owner. |
| Unsent and on-hold claims | Claims created but never sent, or held for attachments or narratives | These are the ones most likely to blow through a filing limit during the gap. |
| Unapplied credits and credit balances | Payments not attached to a procedure, overpayments, patient credits | Messy credits make the new team's first month harder and can hide refunds you owe. |
| Deposits vs posted payments | Recent bank deposits from payers matched to what was posted | Finds money that arrived but was never posted. |
| Appeals in flight | Each appeal with payer, reference number, date sent, deadline, copy of the letter | So nothing restarts from scratch, and no appeal deadline passes unnoticed. |
| Denial history | Recent denials and rejections with reason codes | Shows the new team which payers and claim types keep failing. |
| Monthly KPIs | Collection rate, days in AR, denial rate for the last 6 to 12 months | The yardstick for judging the new company at day 30, 60 and 90. |
Save each report two ways: a PDF snapshot dated the day you pulled it, and a spreadsheet you can sort and assign. The PDF settles arguments later about what was open on which day. The spreadsheet is what you actually work from.
Some of the most useful material never touches the practice management system. Ask for these by name in your notice letter:
Make a simple list of every login the billers use: each payer portal, the clearinghouse, your practice software user accounts, remote access tools, a shared fax or eFax line, and any shared email inbox. For each one, write down whose name the account is registered under and who knows the password. If a portal account belongs to the vendor, you need to set up a practice-owned account before the end date, not after.
Not sure if outsourcing is worth it for your numbers? A free AR analysis shows you your real collection rate, days in AR, and how much is recoverable, before you decide anything.
Get a free AR analysisThis is the part practices skip most often, and it is the one that produces the strangest problems months later. Three separate pieces move your claims and your money, and they are enrolled separately.
EFT is usually the safest of the three, because the money goes to the practice's bank account no matter who does the billing. The ERA is the risk. If the old billing company enrolled your ERAs under its own clearinghouse account, the remittance detail keeps arriving there after you leave. Your money still lands in your bank, but nobody can see which claims it paid, so it does not get posted. The claims look open, the new team works them, and payers tell them the claim was paid weeks ago.
| Your setup | What changes |
|---|---|
| The clearinghouse account is in the practice's name, and the new team will use it | Very little. Remove the old team's users and add the new team's. ERA routing stays the same. |
| The clearinghouse account is in the vendor's name | You need a practice-owned account, new payer ERA enrollments pointed at it, and a check that payer IDs in your software match the new clearinghouse. |
| The new company wants a different clearinghouse | Same as above, plus keep the old account open until claims sent through it have come back, since their status and remittances return on the old route. |
Payer IDs can differ between clearinghouses for the same insurance company, so a switch can mean updating payer records in your software. And because enrollment is handled payer by payer, some payers will be done quickly and others will take weeks. Start with the payers that make up most of your insurance revenue, and start before you give notice if the route is changing.
One quick test before cutover: send a small batch of claims to each of your top payers on the new route and confirm the acknowledgments come back. It is far easier to fix an enrollment problem with ten claims than with three hundred.
Every date in a switch hangs off two decisions: the day you give notice and how long your contract says the notice period runs. From those you get an end date, and from the end date you pick a cutover date, the day the new team starts submitting every new claim. Enter your dates below and the planner lays out the whole timeline, plus a checklist grouped by phase that remembers your progress in this browser.
If you want the short version, there is an 8-step switching checklist on our comparison page. This planner goes further: real dates, a timely filing warning, and the full phase-by-phase list.
Enter your notice date and contract terms. You get a dated timeline and a phase-by-phase checklist. Progress saves in this browser.
The filing limit is a placeholder. Replace it with the shortest timely filing limit in your own payer contracts or provider manuals; it varies by payer and plan.
1. Before notice, finish by
2. Notice period, through cutover on
3. Cutover day, on
4. First 30 days, through
Want to know what is in your AR before the clock starts?
Get a free AR analysis before you give noticeA switch goes best with a short overlap (two to three weeks works well) where both teams are active but with a clear line between them. The line has to be written down. A verbal "we'll sort it out" is how claims end up with no owner.
There are two common ways to draw the line, and either works as long as everyone agrees:
Whatever split you choose, decide in writing what happens on the end date to old-team claims that are still unpaid. Those need to move to the new team with their notes, on a list, on a specific day.
| Work | Before cutover | Cutover to end date | After end date |
|---|---|---|---|
| New claims | Old team | New team | New team |
| Follow-up on claims the old team sent | Old team | Old team | New team, from the handoff list |
| Appeals already in flight | Old team | Old team, with copies to the new team | New team |
| Payment posting | Old team | One named team only | New team |
| Eligibility and verification | Whoever does it today | New team | New team |
Posting deserves its own line. Two teams posting into the same ledger is how payments get posted twice or not at all. Pick one team to post from cutover forward, usually the new one, and tell the other to stop.
During the overlap, sort the open claims list by age every week and confirm each claim over 30 days has an owner and a next action. Our guide to AR over 90 days covers what to do with the old claims that have already slipped. If your office manager runs this check, the office manager duties guide has a sensible way to fit it into the week.
Every payer sets a deadline for submitting a claim after the date of service, and a separate deadline for appeals. The limits differ by payer, by plan and sometimes by contract, so the only reliable source is your payer agreements and provider manuals. Our dental timely filing guide explains how the limits work and how corrected claims and appeals are handled.
A switch raises the risk in three specific ways:
Find your shortest filing limit across your main payers. Then, a week before cutover, pull every unbilled or on-hold service older than that limit minus a few weeks. Those go to the top of the list with a named owner and a due date. The planner above does this math for you: enter your shortest limit and it shows the service date that becomes risky within two weeks of cutover.
Ask both teams to work the clearinghouse rejection report daily during the overlap, not weekly. A rejection fixed the same day costs nothing. A rejection found six weeks later can cost the whole claim.
If a claim does go past the limit, the payer may still accept proof of timely submission, such as a clearinghouse acceptance report showing it was sent on time. That is one more reason to keep the old clearinghouse reports and get copies before the end date. For denials that come back after the switch, the appeals guide and our list of denial codes help the new team move fast.
The end date is a checklist day, not a celebration. Do these on the day, not the following week:
Removing access is a security step, not a judgment on the outgoing company. HIPAA's security rule includes an addressable specification for procedures that end access to electronic patient information when a workforce member's employment or other arrangement ends (45 CFR 164.308(a)(3)(ii)(C)), and the same habit applies to a vendor's users. Ask your compliance advisor how this fits your own policies.
Payer checks and EFTs keep coming for weeks after the switch, many for claims the old team submitted. Your new team should post all of them. If the old contract pays the outgoing company a fee on those collections, agree in writing how you will report them, so you are not reconstructing it from bank statements months later.
The switch is not done on the end date. It is done when the old open claims list is closed and your numbers are steady. Here is a realistic rhythm, measured from cutover.
A dip in the first month is normal while enrollments settle and the new team learns your payers. A dip that is still there at day 60, with no clear explanation, is worth a direct conversation.
Your front desk and insurance coordinator will hear about the switch whether you tell them or not, so tell them first and tell them plainly. Wait until after notice is given if you are worried about word getting back to the outgoing company, but not long after.
If someone on your team handled billing questions with the old company, involve them in the handoff meeting. They know which payer always wants the perio chart, which patient has two plans with a coordination problem, and which claims have a story. That knowledge does not show up in any report.
If you have not picked the new company yet, our guide on what to look for in a dental billing company covers the questions to ask, and the planner above works for any company you choose. Ask any candidate exactly how they handle the overlap and the old open claims; a vague answer there is a warning sign.
For what it is worth, this is how we run it at PracticeAlpha: a dedicated US-based team works inside your existing software (Dentrix, Eaglesoft, Open Dental, Curve or Denticon), so there is no data migration, and most practices are fully transitioned within one to two weeks. We are month-to-month with no setup fees, so the next switch, if you ever want one, is just as simple. If you would like to see exactly what is sitting in your AR before you give notice, start with a free AR analysis.
It depends entirely on your contract. Agreements range from month-to-month with short notice to annual terms that auto-renew unless you give notice before a set date. Check the term, the renewal date, the number of notice days, whether the clock starts when notice is sent or received, and the delivery method the contract requires. Send notice exactly that way and ask for written confirmation of the end date. Have your attorney review anything unclear.
Pull insurance aging by payer, a full open claims list, unsent and on-hold claims, unapplied credits, a deposits-to-posting reconciliation, appeals in flight with copies of the letters, recent denial history and monthly KPIs. Most of this comes from your own practice software, so pull it before you give notice. Then ask in writing for anything stored in the vendor's own systems, such as claim notes, call logs and payer correspondence.
The patient ledger and claim history in your practice management software belong to your practice, but claim notes, appeal letters and tracking spreadsheets may sit in the billing company's own tools. Your contract should say what is returned, in what format and by when. Under HIPAA, the business associate agreement must also require the company to return or destroy patient information at termination where feasible. Ask your attorney to confirm how your specific contract reads.
Yes, and a short overlap usually helps. The key is a written line between them: typically the old team finishes claims it already submitted, the new team submits every claim from the cutover date, and only one team posts payments. Without that line, claims fall between the two teams or payments get posted twice. Two to three weeks of overlap before the contract end date is a workable window.
They need a named owner on every day of the transition. Export the open claims list before notice, agree in writing whether the outgoing team keeps working those claims until the end date, and hand the remaining ones to the new team on a list with notes on the end date. Review that list weekly until every claim is paid, appealed, corrected and resent, or written off on purpose.
Sometimes. EFT deposits go to your practice bank account, so they usually do not change. ERAs are the risk: if the old company enrolled your electronic remittances under its own clearinghouse account, they keep going there after you leave, and payments stop getting posted. Check where each major payer sends ERAs. If the route is changing, start re-enrollment payer by payer before you give notice, because some payers take weeks.
Find the shortest filing limit across your main payers, then pull every unbilled or on-hold service approaching that limit a week before cutover and give each one an owner and a due date. Ask both teams to read the clearinghouse rejection report daily during the overlap, since rejected claims never reached the payer. Keep clearinghouse acceptance reports, which can serve as proof of timely submission if a payer disputes a date.
On the contract end date, not before and not later. Before it, they may still be contractually working your claims. After it, open access is an unnecessary security risk. Remove their practice software users, remote access tools and payer portal accounts, change any shared passwords, and redirect shared fax lines or inboxes. Then confirm in writing that your requested files were delivered and patient data was returned or destroyed.
The calendar is usually set by your current contract's notice period plus a short overlap, and then roughly 90 days of follow-through until the old open claims are closed and your numbers settle. The onboarding itself can be quick when the new company works inside your existing practice software and nothing needs to be migrated. PracticeAlpha, for example, fully transitions most practices within one to two weeks.
Tell them soon after notice is given, in plain terms: a short reason for the change without criticizing the old company, what changes in their daily work, who to send attachments and claim questions to, and the cutover and end dates. Make the office manager the single point of contact for the first month. Include whoever worked most with the old billers in the handoff meeting, since they know the payer quirks no report shows.
Free AR analysis. We pull your aging report, calculate your real collection rate, days in AR, and denial rate, and show you whether outsourcing would actually move the number. 30 minutes. No commitment.