You outsourced billing so you could stop worrying about it, and now something feels off. Here is how to check your billing company's work from your own software, what the numbers mean, and how to raise it before you think about switching.
Last updated November 2026 · Reviewed by the PracticeAlpha billing team
Do not judge your billing company by the reports it prepares. Pull your own from your practice software: insurance aging by payer, production and collections, denials by reason, unapplied payments and write-off adjustments. Turn them into five ratios (net collection rate, days in AR, share of AR over 90 days, denial rate, first-pass rate) and track them month over month. Rising write-offs, slow posting, no named contact or vague answers about specific denials are the red flags.
You hired a billing company so you could stop staring at aging reports. That was the whole point. So when collections feel soft, or a patient calls angry about a balance that should have been paid by insurance months ago, the instinct is to shrug and assume the vendor has it handled.
Here is the uncomfortable part. Outsourcing moves the work, not the ownership. The claims are still yours, the AR is still yours, and when a claim ages past a payer's filing limit, the write-off lands on your books, not theirs. A billing company can be pleasant, responsive on email, and still be quietly letting money slip.
The good news is that you do not need a consultant or a forensic accountant to find out. Every number that matters already lives in your practice management software. You can pull it yourself in about ten minutes, and that is the key word: yourself. A report your billing company prepares tells you what they chose to show you. A report you run tells you what is actually there.
This is a quick health check you can repeat every month. It is not a coding compliance audit (the kind a payer or a state Medicaid program runs to look for billing errors), and it is not a full revenue cycle review. Think of it as taking your vendor's temperature. If the numbers look fine and stay fine, you just bought peace of mind. If they do not, you will walk into the conversation with your billing company holding facts instead of a feeling.
One more thing before you start. This page covers the audit process. If you want a deeper explanation of each metric, what it measures and why it moves, our guide to dental billing KPIs walks through them one at a time.
Log into your practice management software with your own credentials (if you do not have your own login, that is your first finding). Pick one period and use it for everything, either last month or the last three full months. Three months smooths out a slow week or a big check that landed late.
Report names vary between Dentrix, Eaglesoft, Open Dental, Curve and Denticon, but every major system can produce these. If you cannot find one, ask your software's support line, not your billing company. You want to know how to get there on your own.
| Report | What to write down | What a warning sign looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance aging report, by payer | Total insurance AR, and the 0-30, 31-60, 61-90 and 90+ buckets for each payer | One or two payers carrying most of the old balances, or the 90+ bucket growing month over month |
| Production and collections summary | Gross production, contractual adjustments, total collections, insurance collections | Collections falling while production holds steady |
| Procedures completed vs claims sent | The gap between date of service and the date each claim went out, for a sample week | Claims going out days or weeks after the visit, or completed procedures with no claim at all |
| Denials, by reason | Claims denied in the period, grouped by denial reason and payer | The same reason repeating month after month, which means nobody is fixing the root cause |
| Unapplied payments or credit balances | Total dollars received but not applied to a procedure | A balance that keeps growing, which means posting is behind or sloppy |
| Adjustments, by type | Every write-off adjustment, grouped by type and by who entered it | Rising "insurance write-off" or "uncollectible" totals, or old claims vanishing through adjustments instead of payments |
Most owners glance at the total and move on. Do not. Run it by payer and look at the shape. Healthy AR is front-loaded: most of the dollars sit in the newest bucket because claims go out fast and get worked before they age. If the 61-90 and 90+ columns are fat, claims are not being followed up. Our guide on how to read a dental insurance aging report shows what each column means and which balances to chase first.
This one rarely shows up on vendor reports, and it is one of the most telling. Pick a recent week. List every completed procedure that should have been billed to insurance, then find the date each claim was sent. Same-day or next-day is what you are paying for. If you see a pattern of claims going out in weekly batches, or a handful that never went out at all, every day of lag is a day added to your AR before the payer even sees the claim.
Here is a pattern worth knowing. An aging report can look cleaner this month than last month for two very different reasons: claims got paid, or claims got written off. Both shrink the 90+ bucket. Only one puts money in your account. Pull the adjustment report and look at who is entering write-offs, what type they are coded as, and whether the totals are climbing. A billing company should never write off a collectible claim without telling you, and you should be able to see a reason on every one.
Raw dollar figures are hard to compare from month to month because production moves around. Ratios fix that. These are the five that matter for judging a billing company, with the formula for each. Do the math on the numbers you pulled, or let the scorer further down this page do it for you.
| Metric | Formula | Direction you want |
|---|---|---|
| Net collection rate | Total collections divided by (gross production minus contractual write-offs) | High and steady |
| Days in AR | Total AR divided by average daily gross production (production for the period divided by the days in it) | Low, and not creeping up |
| Share of AR over 90 days | AR in the 90+ bucket divided by total AR | Small, and shrinking or flat |
| Denial rate | Claims denied divided by claims submitted, same period | Low and stable |
| First-pass rate | Claims paid on first submission divided by claims submitted | High and steady |
Take a made-up two-provider practice and the last three months (91 days). These numbers are illustrative only, not targets.
Is 17.8% over 90 days good or bad? On its own, you cannot say, and anyone who tells you there is one correct figure for every practice is guessing. Payer mix, specialty and how much Medicaid you see all move these numbers. What tells you something is the trend. If that same practice was at 11% six months ago and has climbed every month since, the billing company is falling behind on follow-up, whatever the industry averages say.
Gross collection rate (collections divided by gross production) reads low by design because it includes discounts you agreed to when you joined each PPO network. It mostly tells you about your fee schedule and payer mix, not your biller. Net collection rate strips those agreed discounts out, so a drop in net is money you had a right to and did not get. Our page on dental collections rate explains the difference in more depth.
One caution: if contractual write-offs are posted inconsistently (some entered as contractual, some lumped in as general write-offs), your net rate will look better than it really is. That is another reason the adjustment report from Step 1 matters.
Not sure if outsourcing is worth it for your numbers? A free AR analysis shows you your real collection rate, days in AR, and how much is recoverable, before you decide anything.
Get a free AR analysisPut the numbers you pulled into the scorer below. It calculates the ratios, then asks you to tick any red flags that are true for your practice today. Everything stays in your browser and is saved on this device, so you can come back next month.
The most useful button is the snapshot. Save one each month and the cards will show whether each number moved in the right direction since your last check. One month of data is a photo. Three or four months is a trend you can take to your billing company.
Enter numbers you pulled yourself from your practice software, all for the same period. Nothing is sent anywhere; entries are saved on this device.
Tick every statement that is true today.
Numbers tell you that something is off. These patterns usually tell you why. Any one of them is worth a question. Several together usually mean the relationship needs a hard reset.
A monthly PDF with a nice chart is not oversight. If the numbers in it cannot be reproduced from your own software, you have no way to check them. A good billing company will happily show you exactly which reports they pulled and how they calculated each figure, so you can run the same thing yourself.
Some write-offs are normal. Contractual adjustments on in-network claims happen every day. What should worry you is a climbing total of insurance write-offs, small-balance write-offs or "uncollectible" adjustments with no explanation attached. Writing off a hard claim is faster than appealing it. That trade-off should be your decision, not your vendor's.
When insurance checks and electronic payments sit for days before they hit patient ledgers, three things go wrong at once. Patients get statements for balances insurance already paid, your front desk cannot quote accurate balances, and underpayments go unnoticed because nobody compared the payment to the expected amount. A growing unapplied payment balance is the giveaway.
If every question goes to a shared inbox and gets answered by someone new, nobody is accountable for your AR. Ask who is assigned to your account. If the answer is a team name or a ticket queue, that tells you how your claims are being handled too.
This is the simplest test on the page. Pick a recent denied claim, give them the patient and date of service, and ask three things: why it was denied, what was done about it, and when it will be resolved. A biller who is working your denials can answer in a sentence. A general answer like "that payer is difficult" means nobody looked. Our guide to dental claim denial codes helps you check whether the explanation you get matches what the payer actually said.
Ratios are averages, and averages hide things. A claim-level spot check takes another fifteen minutes and shows you how the work is really being done. Pull ten claims:
For each one, open the claim history in your software and look for the same handful of things.
| Check | What you want to see |
|---|---|
| Date sent vs date of service | Sent the same day or the next business day |
| Follow-up notes | Dated notes showing someone checked status at regular intervals, with what the payer said |
| Attachments | X-rays, perio charting or narratives included where the payer requires them |
| Denial handling | A corrected claim or appeal sent, with a date, not just a note saying "denied" |
| Payment posting | The payment matches the EOB line by line, and any underpayment is flagged |
| Write-offs | Every adjustment has a reason that makes sense |
The old claims are the most revealing. Picture a crown claim from four months ago with one note from week two saying "pending" and nothing since. That claim is drifting toward the payer's filing limit, and nobody is watching it. If you find that on three of your five oldest claims, you have found the problem, and no monthly summary would have shown it to you.
For the denied claims, check whether an appeal actually went out. Our guide to dental insurance appeals covers what a proper appeal includes. For the paid claims, compare the posted amount to the EOB. If you are not sure what you are looking at, how to read a dental EOB breaks one down line by line.
With the numbers and the claim trace in hand, you can ask sharper questions than "how are things going?" Here are the ones that separate a vendor who is working your account from one who is coasting, and what a good answer sounds like.
| Ask | A good answer sounds like |
|---|---|
| Which reports do you pull for our monthly numbers, and how do you calculate each one? | Specific report names and formulas you can repeat in your own software |
| How soon after the visit does a claim go out? | A specific turnaround, plus how they handle claims waiting on an attachment |
| How often is each unpaid claim followed up, and where are the notes? | A set schedule, with notes recorded in your software where you can read them |
| What are our top three denial reasons, and what are you doing about each? | Named reasons and a root-cause fix, such as a verification step or an attachment rule |
| How fast are payments posted after they arrive? | A specific turnaround, and how they flag underpayments |
| Who approves write-offs, and is there a dollar limit before we are asked? | A clear threshold, with your approval required above it |
| Who is my named contact, and who covers when they are out? | A real person by name, plus a backup |
| What happens to our open claims and appeals if we part ways? | A handoff list, no data held back, and logins that stay in your name |
Watch how the questions land as much as what the answers are. A billing company that is confident in its work tends to welcome the scrutiny. Defensiveness, vague answers or a promise to "get back to you" on basic process questions are information too.
If you are also weighing other vendors while you do this, our guide on what to look for in a dental billing company covers how to evaluate a new one. The questions above are aimed at the one you already have.
Switching billing companies is work. Logins change, open appeals need handing off, and your team has to learn a new contact. Before you go there, give your current vendor one clear, documented chance to fix things. Sometimes the problem is a single overloaded biller, and a direct conversation solves it.
Send a short email before the call. List what you found: the 90+ bucket by payer compared with three months ago, the claim lag from your sample week, the denials with no follow-up, the write-off total. Facts, not adjectives. This does two things. It shows you did the work, and it creates a record if you later need to end the relationship.
Pull out your contract and your business associate agreement now, while things are calm. Look for the notice period, any termination fees, and what happens to your data and open work when the contract ends. Under HIPAA, a business associate contract must address returning or destroying protected health information at termination where feasible, and must authorize the practice to terminate if the business associate violates a material term (see 45 CFR 164.504(e)). Have your attorney review your specific agreement, because the details vary and this is not legal advice.
Also make sure the logins that matter are in your name: your practice software, your clearinghouse account and your payer portals. If the billing company controls the only access, a switch becomes much harder than it needs to be. Our guide on dental clearinghouses explains how that account typically works.
At the check-in date, pull the same six reports and score them again. If the trend has turned, keep auditing monthly so it stays turned. If nothing has moved, you have a documented record of what you asked for, what was agreed and what happened, which makes the next decision simple.
The biggest fear owners have about switching is that claims fall through the cracks during the handoff. That risk is real, and it is manageable if you plan for it.
When a new team starts, the oldest claims are the most urgent because they are closest to filing limits. A good incoming biller works the aging report from the oldest balances down, not from the newest claims up. Ask how they plan to handle that in the first two weeks. Our page on dental AR over 90 days covers how old claims get recovered, and AR recovery is a service in its own right if the backlog is large.
Whoever you move to, hold them to the same audit from the first month. At PracticeAlpha, we work inside your existing software (Dentrix, Eaglesoft, Open Dental, Curve or Denticon), so there is no migration, and most practices are fully transitioned within 1-2 weeks. A dedicated, US-based team is assigned to your practice, claims go out the same day, every unpaid claim is followed up at 30, 60 and 90 days, and payments are posted within 24 hours. The monthly report shows your collection rate, days in AR and denial rate, and you can check every figure against your own software.
Pricing is 3.5% of net insurance collections or $1,995 a month, whichever is higher, with no setup fees and no long-term contract. Month-to-month means we have to keep earning the account, which is how it should be with any billing company.
The single best protection against a slipping billing company is an owner who looks. Not every day, and not at every claim. Once a month, ten minutes, the same reports, the same five numbers. Billing problems compound slowly: a few days of lag here, a denial reason nobody fixes there, a handful of write-offs that should have been appeals. Caught in month one, they are an email. Caught in month nine, they are a recovery project.
If you would rather have someone else do the first pass, the billing health check walks through your setup, and the revenue leak calculator puts a dollar figure on what a few points of collection rate are worth. Or have us pull your aging report and walk you through it in a free 30-minute AR analysis. Either way, the habit is the point. A billing company that knows you are watching tends to stay sharp.
Pull your own reports from your practice management software instead of relying on the vendor's summary: an insurance aging report by payer, production and collections, denials by reason, unapplied payments and write-off adjustments. Turn them into net collection rate, days in AR, share of AR over 90 days, denial rate and first-pass rate. Then watch the trend month over month. Steady or improving numbers, plus clear answers about specific claims, are what a good job looks like.
Six reports cover it: the insurance aging report broken out by payer, a production and collections summary, a comparison of procedures completed against claims sent, denials grouped by reason, unapplied payments or credit balances, and adjustments grouped by type. Run them yourself, with your own login, for the same period. Report names differ between Dentrix, Eaglesoft, Open Dental and other systems, so ask your software support if you cannot find one.
Divide total collections by gross production minus contractual write-offs for the same period. For example, $300,000 collected on $450,000 of production with $135,000 in contractual write-offs gives $300,000 divided by $315,000, or 95.2%. Use net rather than gross because gross includes the PPO discounts you agreed to, so it reads low by design and says more about your fee schedule than your biller.
First find average daily production: gross production for a period divided by the number of days in it. Then divide your total accounts receivable by that daily figure. A practice with $450,000 of production over 91 days averages about $4,945 a day, so $180,000 in AR equals roughly 36 days. The single number matters less than the direction. Days in AR creeping up for several months means collections are slowing.
Watch for reports only the vendor prepares and you cannot reproduce, rising write-offs with no explanation, insurance payments that sit unposted for days, no named contact who knows your practice, and vague answers when you ask about a specific denied claim. A growing 90+ day bucket, claims sent in weekly batches, and old claims leaving the aging report through adjustments rather than payments are also strong warning signs.
Be careful with any single benchmark figure. Payer mix, specialty, Medicaid volume and fee schedules all move collection rate, days in AR and denial rate, so a number that is healthy for one practice can be poor for another. The more reliable test is your own trend: save the same five ratios every month and see whether they hold steady or improve. Two or more moving the wrong way is a reason to ask questions.
Ask which reports they use for their monthly numbers and how each figure is calculated, how soon after the visit claims are sent, how often unpaid claims are followed up and where the notes are, what the top three denial reasons are and what is being done about each, how fast payments are posted, who approves write-offs, and who your named contact is. Specific answers are a good sign. Vague ones are information too.
Usually give them one documented chance first. Email what you found, agree on specific fixes with dates, and judge progress on reports you pull yourself. Allow about 30 days for process fixes like claim lag and posting speed, and 60 to 90 days for old AR to start moving. If the trend has not turned by the check-in date, you have a clear record that supports switching.
Before giving notice, get a handoff list: a current aging report by payer, every open appeal and its status, claims waiting on attachments, payer-specific notes and every login the company used. Make sure your practice software, clearinghouse and payer portal accounts are in your name. Review your contract and business associate agreement with your attorney for notice periods and how data is returned. The incoming team should work the oldest claims first.
Run the quick audit monthly: pull the same reports on the first business day, calculate the same five ratios and compare them with last month. It takes about ten minutes once you know where the reports live. Once a quarter, trace ten individual claims from visit to payment, including your oldest unpaid claims and recent denials. That claim-level check catches problems a monthly summary can hide.
Free AR analysis. We pull your aging report, calculate your real collection rate, days in AR, and denial rate, and show you whether outsourcing would actually move the number. 30 minutes. No commitment.